From a “Society of Scholars” to a Credential Society? The Perceptions of Ultra-Orthodox Students in Israel, regarding HigherEducation and its Influence on Work and Family – a Gender Perspective

  • The authors:
    Yael Yossel Eisenbach
    Sylvie Fogiel Bijaoui
  • Issue: July 24-26th, 2019
  • Pages: 51-56
  • Section: RELIGION IN CONTEMPORARY EDUCATION: INTERCULTURAL COMMUNICATIO AND SOCIAL REFLECTION
  • URL: http://conference-ifl.rudn.ru/51-56/
  • DOI:
    10.22363/09669-2019-51-56

Abstract. Higher education, the heart of the credential race, is a threatening challenge for ultra-orthodox students (Paredes-Collins, 2014). For these students, who live in sectarian religious communities, higher education is viewed with suspicion, as it is associated with forces of destructive potential for their community and identity (Bowman and Smedley 2013; Cole and Ahmadi 2010; Dey et al. 2010; Hartley 2004; Mooney 2010; Pascarella and Terenzini 2011; Zhao 2017). Quite strangely, despite a growing corpus of research on highly religious students pursuing higher education, very little is known about their motivation and experiences and about the policies adopted by academic institutions to cater for their needs. In this paper, we present findings from a study conducted among UltraOrthodox students at an academic college at the center of Israel. The fieldwork was conducted during 2016 and consists of interviews with 132 students, 77 women (58,3%) and 55 men (41,7%). Findings presented here highlight the perceptions of these students, regarding higher education and its influence on work and family. The students come from “a community of scholars” (Hevrat Lomdim), where most men devote their lives to the study of the sacred texts, while women are entrusted with the dual role of caring for the home and supporting the family. However, due to increasing levels of poverty, they are also part of a growing flux of Ultra-Orthodox Israelis, who pursue academic degrees in order to join the labor force. Our data show that Ultra-Orthodox students, both women and men, pursue higher education mostly for economic purposes, i.e. in order to support their family, together with intrinsic motives such as self-fulfillment and intellectual curiosity. However, gender differences were found in students’ perceptions of the contribution of their academic study to integration into the labor market. It was found that Haredi women more than men perceive academic studies as a path that will contribute to their integration into the labor market. These findings reflect the growing impact of credentialism among Haredi women.
After analyzing the implications these findings may have for the students, the Haredi community and educational policies in Israel, we refer, in our conclusion, to the impact credentialism has on religious communities in the “Global Village”.
Keywords: Higher education, ultra-orthodox students, gender, redentialism

Yael Yossel Eisenbach¹, Sylvie Fogiel Bijaoui²
1 The Israel Academic College, Ramat Gan, Israel,
e-mail: yael.eisenbach@gmail.com
ORCID ID: 0000-0003-4522-9952
2 The Israel Academic College, Ramat Gan, Israel,
e-mail: ibii@013net.net

Almond, S., & Perry-Hazan, L. 2011. The ability to claim and the opportunity to imagine: Rights consciousness and the education of ltraOrthodox girls. JL & Educ 40: 273-304.
Ayalon, H., & Yogev, A. 2006. Stratification and diversity in the expanded system of higher education in Israel. Higher Education Policy19(2): 187-03.
Blumen, O. 2007. The gendered display of work: The midday scene in an Ultra-Orthodox street in Israel. NASHIM 13: 123-154.
Blumenfeld, W. J., & Klein, J. R. 2009. Working with Jewish undergraduates. New Directions for Student Services125: 33-38.
Bowman, N. A., and J. W. Brandenberger. 2012. “Experiencing the Unexpected: Toward a Model of College Diversity Experiences and Attitude Change.” The Review of Higher Education 35 (2): 179–205.
Bowman, N. A., and C. Smedley. 2013. “The Forgotten Minority: Examining Religious Affiliation and University Satisfaction.” Higher Education: The International Journal of Higher Education and Educational Planning 65 (6): 745–60.
Bryant, A. N. 2007. Gender differences in spiritual development during the
college years. Sex roles 56(11-12): 835-846.
CBS (Central Bureau of Statistics Israel). 2017 June. “PressRelease185/2017.” CBS. Accessed January 11 2017.http://www. cbs.gov.il/reader/pdf.185e_17_16/hodaot2017n.
Cole, D., and S. Ahmadi. 2010. “Reconsidering Campus Diversity: An Examination of Muslim Students’ Experiences.” The Journal of Higher Education 81 (2): 121–39.
Cowan, R. S. 2018. The “industrial revolution” in the home: household technology and social change in the twentieth century. In Staub, A. (ed.), The Routledge companion to modernity, space and gender. New-York: Routledge.pp. 81-97.
Dehan, N. N. 2013. “Case Study: The First Israeli BSW Program for Haredi Women Students.” Journal of Social Work Education 49 (4): 716–32.
Dey, E. L., M. C. Ott, M. Antonaros, C. Barnhardt, and M. A. Holsapple. 2010. Engaging Diverse Viewpoints: What is the Campus Climate for Perspective-Taking? Washington, DC: Association of American Colleges and Universities.
Edelstein, O. E., Band-Winterstein, T., & Bachner, Y. G. 2017. The meaning of burden of care in a faith-based community: the case of ultraOrthodox ews (UOJ). Aging & mental health 21(8): 851-861.
Hartley, H. V. 2004. “How College Affects Students’ Religious Faith and Practice: A Review of Research.” College Student Affairs Journal 23 (2): 111–29.
JPPI (The Jewish People Policy Institute). 2017. Annual Assessment – The
Situation and Dynamics of the Jewish People. Jerusalem: JPPI.
Mooney, M. 2010. “Religion, College Grades, and Satisfaction among Students at Elite Colleges and Universities.” Sociology of Religion 71 (2): 197–215.
Novis Deutsch, N., & Rubin, O. 2018. Ultra-Orthodox women pursuing higher education: motivations and challenges. Studies in Higher ducation,
Apr 3:1-20.
Paredes-Collins, K. 2014. Campus Climate for Diversity as a Predictor of Spiritual Development at Christian Colleges. Religion & Education 41: 171–93.
Pascarella, E. T., and P. T. Terenzini.2011. How College Affects Students: A Third Decade of Research, The Jossey-Bass higher and adult education series.
Rubin, O., and N. Novis-Deutsch. 2017. Profiles of Haredi Women Pursuing Higher Education: A Cluster Analysis of Diverse Patterns of Motivations and Concerns. Megamot: Journal for Behavioral Sciences (2):109– 140. (Hebrew).
Zhao, Z. 2017. “Religion and the Cultivation of Citizenship in Chinese Higher Education.” Higher Education 74 (4): 635– 649.